My personal opinion about European Studies
The course of European Studies in Italy, and in particular in Padua, is very different from that is in other countries. Indeed it isn’t linked with other school across Europe: this is a pity!I think that the Padua’s course needs to involve, planning a different kind of curriculum. It’s interesting that we have to the possibility to participate in intercultural communication’s projects, using Skype or others platforms, but we need more! We need to apply for certification available in other countries.
An European Studies student needs the possibility to participate in intercultural projects and more international conferences. He needs to trip, visiting other countries and in particular other universities where he can discuss and exchange his view.
An European Studies student need a better knowledge on working inside an European institution, or even the possibility to stage. European Studies course have to focus on the development of skills and competences essentials for an European worker!
2nd December 2012
President François Hollande’s Inauguration Speech
http://ambafrance-us.org/spip.php?article3469#
Making speeches is an hard work for who have to formulate it because of their topics’ organisation, their particular structure and the words’ use.
Being a master of persuading people is very important for a politician because he has to argue on the best way his policies. Making people to agree with himself means gaining a vote or the consent.
How I have just said inside the introduction, while a speech has to be short because the audience has to hear it easily, it needs a particular construction.
Issues need a chronological organisation or coherent too.
Speech needs also a particular words’ structure: it means that it has to include linguistic and grammatical features.
The 15th Mai 2012 François Hollande, who has been sworn as a president of France, during the inauguration ceremony pronounced his first presidential speech.
Focusing on the President Hollande’s Inauguration speech, it’s easy to find the organisation that above I said.
What the topics’ organisation is? Which linguistic and grammatical features are used?
Hollande organised his first discourse in two parts: the first part speaks about the meaning of the word “confidence” and the second one is a message that the new President sends to Europe to embark on get over the crisis.
The first part of the discourse is also divided in 5 paragraph.
In the first paragraph Hollande doesn’t say thanks you for the election, but he immediately introduces the main argument of his speech: the confidence.
First of all he praises the qualities of France for - through his history - having been able to face every kind of challenges.
Secondly he presents himself as the France’s saviour from currents problems.
Next he is fully aware of challenges facing France, which he summarises as huge debt, weak growth, high unemployment, reduced competitiveness and a Europe that is struggling to emerge from the crisis.
Finally he gives to France a positive message: France has good chances to put back on her feet.
The second paragraph starts with the first definition of confidence.
Indeed - from this moment - each paragraph will be introduced by a different definition of confidence.
Hollande says that confidence is the nation’s unity. Using the list of three he emphasises the concept of unity: The country needs calm, reconciliation and to come together.
I will fight racism, anti-Semitism and all forms of discrimination. These two lists don’t consist on a repetition of the same word, but the concept expressed is the same. It’s the best way to underline a concept!
Whatever our age,
whatever our firm beliefs,
wherever we live … in our towns and cities or in our rural areas, we are France.
This is another subterfuge that Hollande uses to underline the concept of unity; indeed this feature gives a particular rhythm to the discourse, catching the attention of the audience.
Finally the concept of unity and cohesion is empathised not only by a contrastive pair as:
Not one France set against another, but a reunited France with the same community of destiny,
but also by a massive repetition of the adjective our.
In the third paragraph the President affirms that he can’t do everything alone. He will be assisted by the Government, the Parliament and the Judiciary. In this paragraph we can notice that the use of the construction “will + infinitive” is massive probably to underline good purposes that Hollande has.
In the fourth paragraph confidence is associated to democracy:
I believe in local democracy…
I believe in social democracy…
I believe in citizens’ democracy…
There is the list of three again.
Inside the two following paragraph the same feature is also used to emphasise first of all the association between confidence and justice Confidence depends on the justice of decisions.
Justice in the very concept of wealth creation
Justice will be the criterion on which each public decision will be taken
and then the idea that Hollande has about young people: That’s the basis of my commitment to the Republic’s schools, because their mission is vital to our country’s cohesion and the success of our economy.
That’s the desire that drives me to modernize professional training, support young people into work and fight job insecurity.
That’s also the admirable idea of civic service that I intend to revive.
they are a resource and for this reason they need support!
The second part of the discourse begins with the seventh paragraph.
Using again the list of three: Europe needs projects.
It needs solidarity.
It needs growth,
Hollande says that he want other European leaders to do something! Europe needs a pact that lies the necessary stimulation of economy.
In the second last paragraph Hollande send a eulogy to France, reminding the previous concept to come together: France is a nation engaged in the world and she will respect all people.
Here there also are the list of three, underlining main important concept:
France … will be true everywhere to her destiny, which is to uphold the freedom of peoples, the honour of the oppressed, the dignity of women.
The eulogy ends in the last paragraph where Hollande gives a long list of his predecessors, saying what they have done and than he takes his responsibilities to represent France in the world.
17th November 2012
Big stereotypes or big truth?
Stereotype is a thought that reflects expectations and briefs about specific types of individuals or certain ways of doing things, that may or not may reflect reality.
How France see her neighbouring countries?
A typical English man for France:
An English is a reserved, polished man with a particular sense of humour. And if there is one things on which everyone agree is the education of British. Indeed they are renowned for being quite reserved: they rarely ask a question about the privacy of the others. Some topic are usually avoided, and typically, in order to break the ice, they start conversations speaking about the weather.
Nevertheless, there is a big difference between people of the North and the South: while in the North (in particular on the British Isles) people have a more relaxed lifestyle, Londoners are dynamic people interacting with others.
What’s about the weather? This is another English cliché. The first image that comes to mind is the rain. It’s exaggerated: the weather is generally neither too hot, nor too cold! It’s only unpredictable: it can be sunny one day and snow the next day.
England is famous for its public transports: London has not only the London Underground, but also the red double-decker bus, that have become iconic! Without forgetting that if you decided to drive, you have to keep your left and get used to see the driver sitting on the right.
English Breakfast is another true stereotype. It is not an exaggeration when we imagine that every mornings they eat sausages, bacon, eggs and beans! However, England has a mixture of culture, which is reflected in culinary: it is not an absurdity finding an English man drinking a cappuccino!
A typical Italian:
Many stereotypes circulate about Italians.
Italians are talkers: kings of human relations, Italians have easy contact. Do not be surprised if it appeals to you in the street exchanging a few words. Italians not only speak with gestures, but also you can hear them talking loudly.
Italians eat pizza, coffee, wine and pasta. Italians are lovers of table’s pleasures. Their gastronomic specialties conquered all the world. But the authentic Italian tradition remains pasta, cooked in many different ways. Italians are generally proud to know how to cook pasta and you will not fail to notice that you are doing it wrong.
Italians are devout Catholics: the majority of Italians are Catholic and one-third of them would go regularly to church on Sunday. This is a stereotype made by the big influence that Church has exercised on the society: indeed it’s common hear references to the Church in the world of Italians.
Italians are sport’s lovers: sport is anther area in which they express their enthusiasm and passion. The national sport is soccer or calcio. Many Italians follow the tournament on television and at the end they have a debate. They also like Formula 1.
Italians have the cult of beauty: they give a great importance to their appearance. The evening walk is assimilate almost to a fashion show. Surprising is that some children in the country celebrate the biggest fashion houses: Armani, Gucci, Prada, Versace, Dolce & Gabbana. The elegance’s research also spills over into the world of objects: for example cars, such as Ferrari, Maserati and Lamborghini.
Italians are mafia: this stereotype comes from many movies, but it’s not the reality! And many Italians don’t like this association with mafia.
France’s point of view about Germany:
The top 10 of Germans' stereotypes:
- Germans always wear white socks with sandals;
- Germans drink only beer;
- Germans eat sausages, wurst and sauerkraut for breakfast;
- Germans listen exclusively metal;
- Germans start their sentence with an “argh”: very inelegant;
- Germans are blond;
- Germans did not have pluck;
- Germans laugh in a gloomy way;
- Germans are light-skinned;
- Germans are careful.
Resources:
http://etudier-voyager.fr/europe/italie-europe/stereotypes-italienshttp://fr.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080202055505AAZyKBOhttp://www.kaplaninternational.com/fr/blog/les-stereotypes-sur-les-anglais-vrai-ou-faux/http://www.topito.com/top-10-des-prejuges-des-francais-sur-les-allemands
11th November 2012
France to make it easier to become French
The new French Interior Minister Manuel Valls last July announced that the new French administration wants to change immigrants policies: the Minister want to move on from the random and discriminatory policies adopted by Sarkozy.
Indeed during the previous administration immigrants were allow to move to France only following a precise procedure.
The biggest discriminatory things inside the list of procedures was the text of French Culture and History. How France can subordinate citizenship to a Culture text? Also Ministers and Senators would find the text difficult to answer!
So, how can immigrants with primary school level education give the correct choice inside the multiple choice text?
Insisting that immigrants have to adapt themselves to French culture and way of living, it’s a sort of discrimination! The new procedures need not only objective selection’s criteria, such as residence, job and family, but also that France give up her idea of nationality, accepting foreigners coming from abroad.
The Interior Minister Manuel Valls, after the abolition of the multiple choice questions, that would have been introduced this year if Sarkozy had been re-elected, announced that he has a plan to make easier to gain French nationality.
Another step forwards to facilitate to obtaining the French nationality is to abolish the requirement of permanent employment contract: at this time it’s very difficult for a French citizen to find a permanent job. So, how immigrants can easily obtain a permanent job before the French nationality?
Valls also affirmed that French nationality should not be sold off or reserved for the elite, but welcomed immigrant has to support the French belief of liberty, egality and fraternity.
Sources: http://www.france24.com/en/20120727-new-french-immigration-initiatives-signal-break-sarkozy-policies-france-manuel-valls-interior-minister
http://www.france24.com/en/20121018-france-make-it-easier-become-french-citizeship-nationality-valls-foreigners-passport#_methods=onPlusOne%2C_ready%2C_close%2C_open%2C_resizeMe%2C_renderstart%2Concircled%2Conload&id=I0_1352628496812&parent=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.france24.com
3rd November 2012
How France focus on American Elections?
“American elections” is the topic which I want to speak about this week and in particular I want to show you what the France vision is.
Before the end of elections (6th November 2012), it’s natural not find politicians’ points of view, because they don’t want to pronounce against or for one of candidates. For this reason I found only 2 article:
http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/the-us-candidates--election-debate-by-ian-buruma/french
“American presidential beauty” by Ian Buruma.
This article is written by Ian Buruma, who is a professor of Democracy, Human Rights and Journalism at Bard College.
Buruma says that in the context of American elections the use of the term “debate” is wrong: for the professor the American presidential debate is very different from French debate. The gap is that the first one is like a performance, where journalists are carefully selected and the answer to every possible question have been planned; the second one, instead, is a real debate with substantive arguments.
In America the president is elected for how he appears in front of public opinion: if the candidate come across a friendly guy, he has more possibilities to became the president!
The winner is not who has the best policies, but who has the best presentation, or seems more accommodating. So the debates are not a political struggle, but a personality contest.
In France it’s absurd to choose the president for how he appears in public (and not for his policies): choosing the country’s president on the basis of his presentability on television is arbitrary and frivolous!
In my opinion nowadays it’s very difficult to not be influenced by candidates’ life, because I think that everyone wants that the official face, that represents the country to the outside world, seems better than the others.
http://www.24hgold.com/francais/actualite-or-argent--lections-americaines--gros-sous-et-pensee-critique.aspx?article=4087434542G10020&redirect=false&contributor=J%C3%A9r%C3%A9mie+T.+Rostan
“American elections: big financing and critical point of view” by Jérémie Rostan.
This article is written by Jérémie Rostan, who affirms that Americans elections are influenced by business financing.
The big businesses with their money can bribe not only voters, but also politicians that can do their favours. The reason is that in America, contrary to France, political financing is free.
In 2009 in a study two economists noticed that, after Bush’s re-election, the share of 30 companies grow up more than others.
But what’s the truth about this problem? Does the big businesses influence power’s exercise? Or politician, when are elected, can cut in on economical situation?
It’s normal that companies have financing strategies living for candidates’ plan!
We doesn’t need to be an economist to understand that insurance companies will get out of Obama’s re-election!
So, in this context, it isn’t natural to think that business want to influence the power?



I have found interesting both the articles Giorgia wrote about and synthesized, each one of them focusing on typifying features of American campaign’s election. Both stress the difference among American and European political attitude on the two sides, public opinion and politicians running for the chair.
ReplyDeleteStigmatizing both approaches, I agree with Professor Baruma where argues the difference between American and European debates even if in my opinion is conceptually wrong to consider the American one not a debate. It is, while presenting features deeply different than the European stereotype. The American is more structured moreover having an high dose of spectacle - element missing in the European political life - differences due to the culture.
American performances presents much more strategy than there is in the Europeans. American contests are brought forward almost scientifically, surely more to hit than to persuade by topics, which depends on the kind of auditorium.
In my opinion is simplistic to argue the President is elected for how his presentation is, reducing the whole to the ability to sell himself and his strategy. It is reductive also because the electorate can not to be achieved by “nice face, beautiful words” only. There is also an high educated and updated electorate voting which assesses the proposals’ validity. it seems the electorate is won thanks to a good presentation only probably because the Europeans do not share the main topics of American political programs (such as mission to bring democracy, finance..).
I have found the last two paragraph first article irreconcilable: in the second last paragraph is written it is not rational to choose a President basing on how he is presented on television, in the last one the electorate is inevitably influenced by their life thus how they present themselves and are presented on the television and newspapers.
The second article stress another feature distinguishing American way of doing politics and the European one. In the U.S. the large corporations influence fundraising necessary for the election campaign, “hollywoodly” expensive. Such phenomenon does not exist in Europe where commingling politics-money is generally not well considered.
Surely the economic interests are one of the most obscure and controversial side of the American elections and Presidencies, one example for all the highly criticized connections linking the former Republic President George W. Bush and large oil companies owners. Obviously the Presidencies are conditioned by interests’ balance of Corporations which contributed during the election and keep on support the President throughout the term.
Valentina Lonardi
Comment corrected
ReplyDeleteI have found interesting both the articles Giorgia wrote about and synthesized, each one of them focusing on typifying features of American campaign’s election. Both stress the difference among American and European political attitude on the two sides, public opinion and politicians running for the chair.
Stigmatizing both approaches, I agree with Professor Buruma where he argues the difference between American and European debates even if in my opinion it is conceptually wrong to consider the American one not a debate. It is, despite it presents features deeply different than the European stereotype. The American one is more structured, moreover having an high dose of spectacle – element missing from the European political life - differences due to culture.
American performances present much more strategy than the Europeans. American contests are brought forward almost scientifically, surely more to hit than to persuade by topics, which depends on the kind of auditorium.
In my opinion it is simplistic to argue the President is chosen thanks to his image only, reducing the whole to the ability to sell himself and his strategy. It is reductive also because the electorate can not to be achieved by “nice face, beautiful words” only. There is also an high educated and updated electorate voting, which assesses the proposals’ validity. It seems the electorate is won thanks to a good presentation probably because the Europeans do not share the main topics of American political programs (such as mission to bring democracy, finance..).
I have found the last two paragraph first article irreconcilable: in the second last paragraph it is written it is not rational to choose a President basing on how he is presented on television, in the last one the electorate is inevitably influenced by their life thus how they present themselves and are presented on the television and newspapers.
The second article stresses another feature distinguishing American way of doing politics and the European one. In the U.S. the large corporations influence fundraising necessary for the election campaign, “hollywoodly” expensive. Such phenomenon does not exist in Europe where commingling politics-money is generally not well considered.
Surely the economic interests are one of the most obscure and controversial side of the American elections and Presidencies, one example for all the highly criticized connections linking the former Republican President George W. Bush and large oil companies owners. Obviously the Presidencies are conditioned by interests’ balance of Corporations, which contributed during the election and keep on support the President throughout the term.
Valentina Lonardi
Nowadays it's not easy for an immigrant to become a citizen of a Nation. I was really surprise when i read this post because I didn’t know that in France, with the new law made by Sarkosy, everything was changing. Actually I think that the new president Hollande has taken the right choice when his Interior Minister Manuel Valls decided to remove Sarkozy's law linked with immigration. I totally agree with Giorgia: how we can pretend that an immigrant could be able to answer to lots of questions about culture when even people that were born in that nation and they never leave it, they can't do?
ReplyDeleteI always be interested about this topic because i always want to have the double citizenship but until now I can't have it.
Searching on the web between European nations I found that only in Poland it is very easy to become a Polish citizen. Over there it's enough to demonstrate that you have lived there for at least 5 years or to be married with a Polish citizen for at least three. Instead in Spain, although immigrants should not pass a formal investigation, in fact the law allows judges to prepare a report on the level of adaptation of immigrants, to put questions to the candidates at their discretion to assess the degree of integration into the culture and style of Spanish life in order to avoid" cheating ".In Italy, since 1992 the text has been removed, but the police usually has two or three questions to the candidate while in Germany the test was introduced in September 2008. Many have complained of an alleged discrimination in the examination to Muslims and and other have questioned the compatibility of this law with the German Constitution.
So in my opinio it's a good thing what Hollande's government has decided to do in order to change immigrant's policies. I believe that it will be more useful to promote other ways in order to integrate immigrants for example some compulsory class in order to improve their language skill.
Annie Ishebabi