Showing posts with label iron curtain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label iron curtain. Show all posts

Monday, 3 December 2012

We must not let it happen again. Winston Churchill and his Sinews on Peace.




After theWorld War II  was over, the British Prime Minister Winston Churchill felt in his duty to place before the Americans real facts about the then current situation in Europe. In his post-war speech, technically titled "Sinews of Peace",  known better as "The Iron Curtain Speech", Mr. Churchill addresses the audience of Westminster College in Fulton and the President Truman ( March 5, 1946). In order to describe the ideological and political division of Eastern from Western Europe he used for the first time the term of the  iron curtain: 

" From Stettin in the Baltic to Trieste in the Adriatic an iron curtain has descended across the Continent. Behind that line lie all the capitals of the ancient states of Central and Eastern Europe. Warsaw, Berlin, Prague, Vienna, Budapest, Belgrade, Bucharest and Sofia, all these famous cities and the populations around them lie in what I must call the Soviet sphere.... " 

The paragraph's of the Churchill's speech are quite long and can be summarized in the following manner:

1- Addresses audience ( President Mr. Cluer, ladies and gentlemen, President of the United States of America)
2-5 - Thanks and acknowledgments
6-8 - Need to ensure peace in the world
9-11-  Prevention of further wars through the  United Nations Organization and proposal for an international armed force
12-15 - The threat of tyranny in Europe
16-18 Special relationship between English- speaking peoples ( British Commonwealth and the Empire, the USA and Canada)
19- Temple of Peace between workmen of all countries
20-23 - Who is the enemy? Soviet Russia and its Communist international organizartion
24- Europe must be united such as the USA
25-26 - Communist parties inside western countries of Europe
27-29 Western democracies must stand together
30-31 We must not let it happen again!

This kind of division of the speech makes clear the aims of it. Winston Churchill was aware of needing support of the USA, without which neither Europe nor the United Nations Organization could have survived from the threat of the Soviet Russia. 
In this speech it is not specified the point where the audience applause. However, we can identify the soundbites and claptraps in the text. ( it is important to keep in mind the post war context of the speech)- The main phrases and word which give us the sensations of emphasis are:

American Democracy, Opportunity is here and now, Freedom and Rights, Allied victory, there is no true deomocracy, a new unity in Europe, we must not let it happen again. 

As far as personal involvment of the speaker is concerned, Churchill at the beginning of his speech  clarifies: " Let me however make it clear that I have no official mission or status of any kind, and I speak only for myself. There is nothing here but what you see." To be precise, he frequently uses the pronoun I when he speaks about what happens in Europe, the threat of Soviet Russia and the proposal to build an international armed force. 
On the other hand, he uses the pronouns WE and OUR talking about British allied countries in order to call to action and to do not be unconcerned to Europe's division. In other words, he stresses on the duty to be responsible to the european partners because of the special relationship between Western Europe ( in particular British Commonwealth) and the United States of America. 
Refering to the facts happened during the war Churchill make use of modal verb "might" focusing on the past and on what could be avoided.  Talking about the future he commonly uses the verb "must" underlining the duty of countries and future generations to prevent the new war and to build the " Temple of Peace" in the whole world.

Furthermore, there is a stong but implicit contrapposition between "us" and "them":

US: English-speaking peoples, democracy, cottage homes, ordinary people, special relationship, united nations, Europe, Western democracies etc.

THEM: tyranny, iron curtain, no true democracy, shadow, communist parties etc. 

Eight days after the speech, russian journal "Pravda" pubblished a bitter condamtion of it, expressing Stalin's indignation that Churchill's remarks were sowing discord among the Allied governments. When Prime Minister Clement Attlee of Great Britain was asked to comment on the speech, he diplomatically retreated with a "no comment" response to Churchill's warnings.